FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. – In the penalty trial of Florida
school shooter Nikolas Cruz, a defense mental health expert can pinpoint when
he realized the 23-year-old mass murderer still has "irrational
thoughts" — the two were making small talk when Cruz began describing
plans for an eventual life outside prison.
Wesley Center, a Texas counselor, said that happened last
year at the Broward County jail while he was fitting probes into Cruz's scalp
for a scan to map his brain. The defense will try to persuade Circuit Judge
Elizabeth Scherer this week that Center and other experts should be allowed to
testify about what their tests revealed in Cruz's ongoing trial, something the
prosecution wants barred.
"He had some sort of epiphany while he was in (jail)
that would focus his thoughts on being able to help people," Center told
prosecutors during a pretrial interview this year, according to transcripts.
"His life's mission was to help others."
Of course, Cruz will never be free. Since his arrest on Feb.
14, 2018, about an hour after murdering 14 students and three staff members at
Parkland's Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, there has never been any doubt
that his remaining years would be spent behind bars, sentenced to death or life
in prison without the possibility of parole. Surveillance video shows him
mowing down his victims with an AR-15-style semiautomatic rifle, and he
eventually confessed, pleading guilty in October.
Over three weeks, prosecutors made their case for death to
the seven-man, five-woman jury and ten alternates, finally resting their case
Aug. 4 after the panel toured the still-bloodstained, bullet-pocked classroom
building where the massacre occurred.
The jurors were also shown graphic surveillance videos,
gruesome crime scene and autopsy photos, emotional testimony from teachers and
students who witnessed others die, and stories from tearful and angry parents,
spouses, and other family members about the victims and how their loved one's
death affected their lives. They saw video of the former Stoneman Douglas
student calmly ordering an Icee minutes after the shooting and then attacking a
jail guard nine months later.
Soon, Cruz's attorneys will argue why he should be spared,
hoping to persuade at least one juror that their mitigating circumstances
outweigh the prosecution's aggravating circumstances — a death sentence
requires unanimous consent.
But first, the trial adjourned last week to allow some
jurors to attend to personal matters. The jury will also be absent this week as
the parties argue before Scherer, who will decide whether brain scans, tests,
and other evidence presented by the defense beginning Aug. 22 is scientifically
valid or junk, as the prosecution claims.
The Center's test and its findings will be hotly debated. A
"quantitative electroencephalogram," or "qEEG," as its
supporters refer to it, provides useful support to diagnoses such as fetal
alcohol syndrome, which Cruz's attorneys claim caused his lifelong mental and
emotional problems.
EEGs have been used in medicine for over a century to help
doctors diagnose epilepsy and other brain disorders by measuring brainwaves.
However, qEEG analysis, which has been around since the 1970s, takes it a step
further by comparing a patient's EEG results to a database of brainwaves taken
from normal or "neurotypical" people. While qEEG findings cannot be
used to make a diagnosis, supporters argue that they can support findings based
on the patient's history, examination, behavior, and other tests.
In his interview with prosecutors, Center stated that a
"qEEG can confirm what you already know, but it cannot create new
knowledge."
Emory University neurology professor Dr. Charles Epstein
reviewed the Center's findings for the prosecution. In a written statement to
Scherer, he stated that EEGs using only external scalp probes, such as the one
given to Cruz, are imprecise, rendering the Center's qEEG results meaningless.
He wrote, "Garbage in, garbage out."
Since 2010, when the test helped a Miami-area man avoid the
death penalty for fatally stabbing his wife and severely injuring her mentally
disabled 11-year-old daughter, Florida judges have issued mixed verdicts on
allowing qEEGs. Some judges have since allowed them to enter, while others have
barred them. Scherer, who is presiding over her first death penalty trial, has
never heard of a defense attempt to present a qEEG report.
Even if Scherer rules against the test, lead defense
attorney Melisa McNeill and her team have evidence that Cruz's brain was likely
damaged in the womb, including statements from his late birth mother that she
abused alcohol and cocaine while pregnant.
They also have reports proving his mental illness by
circumstantial evidence. Cruz was expelled from preschool for causing harm to
other children. He spent a significant amount of time in a center for students
with emotional issues during his years in public school. In addition, he
received years of mental health treatment.
Then there's his personal situation. Cruz was bullied by his
younger brother and his brother's friends; he was allegedly sexually abused by
a "trusted peer;" he cut himself and abused animals; and his adoptive
mother died less than four months before the shooting.
His youth will also be an issue; he was 19 at the time of
the shooting.
According to attorneys who are not involved in the case, if Scherer wants to avoid having a potential death sentence overturned on appeal, she should give the defense broad leeway in what it presents so jurors can fully assess his life and mental health.
"If it's a close call, I think she'll bend to the defense — and the prosecution will be furious," said David S. Weinstein, a Miami criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor.
© Copyright The Watchtower 2010 - .
Comments (4)
Wendy Coloes
Feb 27, 2025
This event has left many lessons for everyone about the perseverance needed in today's life. @Geometry Dash Lite...
Viumki
Feb 17, 2025
the little emoji's expression is laid-back and relaxing; in the following levels, it becomes completely irate run 3
andreeoren24
Feb 06, 2025
Step onto the college football stage with Retro Bowl College ! Recruit, strategize, and take your team all the way to bowl game success.
Dustin Shelby
Jan 02, 2025
The traps in house of hazards are extremely sophisticated and diverse, from simple traps like deep holes to complex traps like sharp saw blades. Every time you overcome a trap, the player will feel extremely excited and satisfied.
Write a Comment